Rivers are an important resource for human settlement and economic activity, but flooding is an increasing problem which can hinder development. Read the following two views about ways to manage flooding in Pakistan:
B Flooding brings benefits so rivers should be allowed to flood naturally.
A More flood management schemes are needed along rivers to prevent floods. Which view do you agree with more?
Give reasons to support your answer and refer to examples you have studied. You should consider View A and View B in your answer.
B Flooding brings benefits so rivers should be allowed to flood naturally.
A More flood management schemes are needed along rivers to prevent floods. Which view do you agree with more?
Give reasons to support your answer and refer to examples you have studied. You should consider View A and View B in your answer.
Add an Answer
More Questions From This User See All
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
Answer:
I don't have personal opinions, but I can present arguments for both views to help you form your own perspective.
**View A: Flooding brings benefits so rivers should be allowed to flood naturally.**
1. **Ecosystem Benefits:** Natural flooding can contribute to the health of river ecosystems, promoting biodiversity and providing fertile soil.
2. **Cultural and Agricultural Traditions:** Some communities rely on seasonal flooding for agricultural practices, such as in the case of the Nile River's annual floods that historically enriched the soil in Egypt.
3. **Mitigating Droughts:** Floodwaters recharge groundwater, helping in times of drought by maintaining water availability.
**View B: More flood management schemes are needed along rivers to prevent floods.**
1. **Population Safety:** In densely populated areas, natural flooding can lead to loss of lives and property. Flood management schemes can mitigate these risks.
2. **Infrastructure Development:** Floods can hinder economic development by damaging critical infrastructure like roads and bridges. Flood management can safeguard these structures.
3. **Predictability and Control:** Implementing flood management schemes provides a level of predictability and control, allowing for planned water release and minimizing the impact of floods.
**Considering Pakistan:**
In Pakistan, the Indus River is crucial for agriculture and settlement. Historically, the Indus River's floods have played a role in replenishing soil fertility. However, rapid urbanization and population growth have increased the vulnerability of communities to flooding.
**Conclusion:**
A balanced approach might involve a combination of natural flood management and engineered solutions, considering the specific needs and challenges of each region along the rivers. Integrated strategies that respect the ecological benefits of natural flooding while protecting communities through well-designed flood management schemes could be a viable solution.
Answer:
Both View A and View B present valid perspectives on managing flooding in Pakistan. However, I lean towards View A, suggesting that allowing rivers to flood naturally can bring benefits.
Natural flooding can contribute to the replenishment of soil fertility through sediment deposition, supporting agriculture in riverine areas. Additionally, it helps maintain the ecological balance of river ecosystems. For example, the annual flooding of the Indus River historically played a crucial role in sustaining agricultural productivity in the region.
While View B emphasizes the need for flood management schemes, it's essential to consider the potential ecological and social consequences of altering natural river processes. Large-scale infrastructure projects may disrupt ecosystems and displace communities. In contrast, embracing natural flooding patterns can promote sustainability and resilience in the face of changing climate conditions.
It's crucial, however, to strike a balance. Implementing localized and eco-friendly flood management strategies, such as afforestation and restoring wetlands, can complement natural processes without compromising the overall benefits of periodic flooding.