1. Personalized Friendship Keepsake: Create a special keepsake that represents your friendship, such as a custom photo album with pictures of your online memories together or a customized map highlighting the locations where you both live.

2. Inside Jokes Surprise Box: Compile a box filled with little gifts and items that reference inside jokes and shared interests you both have. Each gift can be accompanied by a note explaining the connection to the joke or interest.

3. Virtual Game Night Kit: As a way to break the ice during your first meet, prepare a virtual game night kit. Include board games, trivia cards, or online multiplayer games that you can play together to make the experience more enjoyable and memorable.